RunFaps
Professor Quill
Professor Quill patreon

Patron Idea Poll

🕑 Added 2023-09-13 23:23:26 +0000 UTC

Comments

MN01

The idea behind my prompt for those of you who aren't on the discord or didn't see the discussion there goes back from that discussion. Some people like to compare Rita to Umbridge, which simply isn't the case. She may have a few unpleasant traits but is ultimately a just cyncial realist and survivor trying to make a living. I doubt she'd go as far as to torture and kill people like Umbridge. I think she tried to be a better reporter when she was younger but became disillusioned and cynical to the point she just gave up as the Prophet "Only exists to sell itself" in her words. She also tried to get into the Slug Club in school likely to make better connections but an ill timed prank by one Bilton Bilmes caused her to lose her chance after she'd put a lot of effort into getting invited and she resented him ever since. And she clearly isn't an untalented Witch considering she became an Animagus on her own with seemingly no help. And there is plenty of evidence that when she puts her mind to it, she can actually write accurate articles and books. Based on what I've seen in her history bio, she does have the traits of someone who is hardworking, intelligent, a good networker, and trying to fight for a place for herself in this world of theirs. I imagine at first she was optomistic and hopeful she could be an intrepid journalist, exposing truth and corruption, championing good causes with integrity that sort of thing. But working for the Prophet and the propaganda machine it turned out to be turned her bitter and cynical while grinding her down until she eventually gave up her old dream. One of the reasons she could dislike Hermione is that she used to be like her in a way. And Hermione makes her remember a time that she was even hopeful and actually looked forward to be journalist and novelist. That Journalists have very stressful jobs on top of this probably didn't help her outlook in life any as time passed. From the lowest beat reporter to the news media executive, this is one of the most stressful careers around. Journalists have to deal with deadlines, busy work environments, crazy schedules, travel, demanding editors, a more demanding public, and the fear of being laid off. Being that the Prophet is Britian's only known Magical Newspaper (and one of the few print medias) just adds to this on top of it being heavily censored by the Ministry. The rest are just magazines and books. And we actually see what happens to a reporter who doesn't print what they want in the Magical world via Rita herself when she's forced to not write her usual pieces in the year after the Triwizard Tournament. As when we next see her she's not looking too hot. Rowling portrayed Rita badly due to bias toward Journalists. So a lot of potential was lost with this character methinks. I mean more nueanced characters are always a good thing. As people are made up of many parts wouldn't you agree. And to those who say she'd be too old for Harry and she's was an unpleasant person. I point towards the numerous fanfictions involving Narcissa, Bellatrix, and other reformed (or not) female Death Eaters stories or the ones involving him with Amelia, Appoline, etc.

Reiter

It's a really good idea!

Mike

The Zamu one sounds really interesting. Hope it wins

cappyz

The Zamu one seems like you can make a whole story out of it

LizzyKat

same here !

Sage Berthelsen

Voted for Zamu but I also want a MN01.

noru

Can't wait for next month so I can try for NovexPrime's idea again 💪

MrHolbyta

Same, but reversed. I'm really intrigued by the GoF aging Harry up and think it's quite fresh and new (a rarity in fanfiction). The MN01 story is more conventional, but has real heart and represents a fascinating story. I really want both.

V_Arko

Please do MN01 it sounds super interesting. But I love the zamu one too.

zamu

Woah! Talk about surprise wasn't expecting to see mine up here.

HowlerAtTheMoon

Zamu, I always like Harry with the lesser known characters

IgnisHeart

AJT, zamu and MN01 are definitely my favorite promts.

That Warden

MN01 sounds like the best one to be honest, im voting for that one.

Professor Quill

The way I would write the Tonks one would be that she doesn't know she's pregnant until after Harry flees from the wedding. They don't meet again until the war is over.

James

Tonks is my fav character, but neither of her prompts really grab me. Honestly, hiding Teddy's parentage from Harry for so long is the worst thing she could possibly do to Harry, who desires family more than anything - to miss his firstborn child's early years would break his heart. I don't understand people's like of that venomous bitch Rita Skeeter, so by process of elimination more than anything else I'll have to vote for Aurora Septima.

Season

Okay that Zamu one is brilliant even if not with Vector that is an amazing setup as a prompt/ jumping off point for a few good stories. Really like that setup

Scott

The idea by zamu is really interesting, but I want more rita/harry out there

Matt

I honestly like both Tonks prompts.

Teklife

Yes to all

LockNesTom

I need that Harry/Rita story. It's such a forgotten pairing and can be amazing if done right

David Zimmerle

Harry/Rita is quite rare so definitely voting for those


More Creators