RunFaps
Professor Quill
Professor Quill patreon

Lucinda's Character Poll 1

🕑 Added 2024-05-20 10:00:13 +0000 UTC

Comments

Stormfox2

Harry/Katie would be great, there is wayy too little stuff with her

Michael Guidebeck

I always love Harry/Katie interactions so that has my vote.

Bruce

I too enjoyed Tutor Me. I enjoy seeing Hermione come out of her shell.

whatsnext444

I also enjoyed "Tutor Me". But I've been away for awhile, a lot to catch up on. Plus, it's always Hermione for me. Such an incredible witch.

Gamerdood

I actually quite liked tutor me but all stories must end sooner or later. Look forward to this going forward.

Professor Quill

Yes, it's been in a poll or two before, just never won.

MasterKronus

I believe I remember this idea being suggested before, and I really liked it with Hermione. I suppose some might find it tiring, but I don't tire of my favorite pair.

Lettered Wolf

Has the Lucinda's blurb been in a story before like one of the old monthly poll ones or a blurb from one of the monthly polls, I sware I read that before. About Tutor me, it is on my list of stories to read when I have time but it isn't at the top. It isn't because Hermione was a major viewpoint character (for the record I think I read the first chapter so I could have details wrong) it was because it was an alternative universe where I have no connection to them, yeah they are versions of our heroes but they aren't them. Older versions of our heroes, I'd care about though. I voted for Katie only because I love her but find her underrepresented, I'd be happy with Hermione in the new story. I'm guessing older Hermione has had some of her sharp edges worn off

Douglas Braning

In the Lucinda poll I would have added the Patil sisters, Professor Vector or, Professor Sinestra(sp??). Or possibly all four🤷‍♂️ I recommended the two Professors with the thought that two relatively young female Professors need "relief" after working around so many 7th years without having any allowable males/female partners.

Jonas Kairiūkštis

Speak for yourself.

DNAjester

I think the low popularity is because of the female MC

jp9901

Same. Ravenclaw representation has been on Luna's (and occasionally Cho's) shoulders. Give Penny a chance

JTC RAGE

Katie has always been a favorite for pairing with Harry. Not enough out there.

Professor Quill

You're voting for the POV.

Professor Quill

You're voting for the POV.

rlmsbpjpp

If you really feel the need to change characters, Penny feels like an underrated character for this storyline… I also like the idea of a less used character like Katie but definitely not Lavender or Demelza. Hermione clearly works too but then Im a sucker for H/Hr. I liked Tutor Me but feel the challenge with a story like it is rewriting the backstory of H&Hr’s relationship so that they’re essentially strangers without actually providing the full backstory of each character; makes it hard to connect with the characters…. Like Hermione basically becomes a Susie Q despite bearing the name Hermione. I almost didnt get past the first couple chapters because of it but it became easier as the chapters went on just to see Harry & Hermione as “Harry & Hermione” without the history between them being rewritten, just Hermione not knowing Harry had such an active dating life or was so helpful to the girls. Demelza has the same problem of being a Susie Q in all but name since there really isn't much known about her at all beyond her infatuation and attempt to dose Harry with a love potion. Certainly other characters have similar weak backstories like the Greengrass sisters or really anyone on this list beyond Demelza but at least there's more within canon to build on.

Jonas Kairiūkštis

Yeah, we need clarification on what are we voting on? (Edited: ) Also dear Professor if you want to tell story your way don't listen to naysayers, it can only hurt your creativity. It's your stories to begin with.

FicFinder

Sorry, is this a poll for whose POV the story is told from, or is it just characters in the story? The wording at the top is a bit contradictory

Stormfox2

Would be happy if it’s somebody else than Hermione, too much


More Creators