RunFaps
Professor Quill
Professor Quill patreon

Falling For Fleur: Chapter 1

🕑 Added 2022-07-21 12:38:55 +0000 UTC

Comments

Grant

You actually see it very often. In poetry, in scripts, and in a multitude of published media. When you don't see it, you see attentive detail frequently directing the reader to read it in an accent (by including their native words, or subtle descriptions). Many more of the world's languages spell things the way they sound. If you're interested in examples look for characters written by authors who speak Creole, Hatian, Russian, any number of Native American languages, or Japanese. Outside a character, you'll find perfect english, but in dialogue, you'll see improper or outright broken english.

Cqys

You're free to believe that I suppose but there's a reason that you basically never see phonetically written accents in published written works. They are simply not exactly fun to read. If the character is supposed to struggle expressing themselves it's generally something that should be done with their interactions with other characters within the story and not because the reader struggles to literally read written words. There's a gigantic gulf between my reading a bunch of z's and missing letters than hearing the accent itself. It doesn't translate well. As a reader you already know she has an accent. If you want to show her struggle with it than it should be reflected through Harry. But he doesn't struggle. At all. It's just something that's there.

Grant

I've read stories where she speaks fluent english. It seriously detracts from the authenticity of the dialogue. The difficulty we experience reading her "Frenglish" is an analog of how difficult it is for her to express herself and be understood on foreign soil.

Boaip

I saw a similar start in a fic that I don't remember the title. In that one Harry saves Fleur using wandless magic. I don't even remember if it was a good story or not. This one seems promising.

Cqys

Strong start. That said is... Is it really necessary to type out Fleur's accent phonetically? The readers know she has one and it gets pretty arduous to read. I think the dialog would flow better with a balance. Write out say... That Fleur doesn't say her H's but replacing TH with Z and I with EE can make... Some things a chore to read. Just something to think about.

Joe

Excellent chapter! Feel like that may be the strongest start to one of your stories yet.

Lyman Louie

Very nice. A very enjoyable read. Like the flow so dar.

Nicholas Carlstrom

Okay, all good. :)

Professor Quill

Not in this one. This story is just going to focus on Harry and Fleur. I may bring in another girl, but it will only be for a chapter or two, nothing permanent.

Nicholas Carlstrom

Is there a hint of Harry/Hermione/Fleur? (Sorry, I’m always going to barrack for Harmony.)

Silver Wolf

Excellent premise! A very plausible divergence point to base a new kind of story. Fleur meets Harry at his best first instead of just a kid with a famous name who is her competition. Just don't go too far in making Fleur less haughty than she is in the books. She's still the same person but under a new influence you've created, so they'll be growing pains. I look forward to your next chapter!

Cateagle

Very nice start! I can see that *this* Fourth Year is going to be much more interesting than in canon and with more goodness to balance the nonsense.

adorsey

His is a great start!!!

whatho

Banger, nice to see a story start early in book 4

Alatoic

Love it!, the action was well done, the reaction of fleur and Harry well made, cant wait for next chapter.

Shawn

Interesting chapter looking forward to the next one

Markus Ellis

Love it!

Zenny

This was a great read

Miles

more please. this was excellent

tornadoboy

Well that ought to make it easy to get a date for the Yule Ball xD


More Creators