RunFaps
Professor Quill
Professor Quill patreon

Pandora's Box: Chapter 8 (Harry/Susan Poll Winner)

🕑 Added 2022-06-11 22:40:38 +0000 UTC

Comments

Erinnyes

Ahhh, Snape's long overdue chewing out. Wonderful work with that and the rest of the chats. A lot of closure was needed and obtained here. Were we only so fortunate in real life.

tornadoboy

Damn I really liked this chapter. Giving closure to a bunch of people is a fantastic idea IMO. Handled the Dursleys particularly well. I do have a few thoughts though. With Snape, i think Lily would have been more upset about how he treats all his students. I know she brings it up in the end, but Snape was basically abusing students for years. It's not just Harry he picks on, and the fact that he's an abuser arguably even worse than the Dursleys is kinda why i really dislike book!Snape. I did love how it was handled though, particularly the revelation of a sister. Just think Lily should have emphasized the others a bit more. My other thought is maybe a bit cruel and dark. But I'm wondering if maybe Neville might be stronger if his parents aren't cured outright. His relationship with his grandmother, the empathy he learns from loving his mother even when his grandmother is somewhat short with her, the resilience he picks up. I think Neville's parents being as they are is a key element to defining him. Maybe a quick fix for them wouldn't be best. The books do imply that over the years his parents improved. So maybe Rowena could find a method that improves their love and eventually heals them, but it's still years of therapy. It gives Neville hope and something to arrive towards, without it being too quick and easy a fix. Even the magical world should have some tragedies i think. Overall I really think this is one of your best stories. Fantastic chapter again! PS: Also excellent job on the Lily and James dynamic. James jumping in when Snape is mentioned was utterly hilarious. And he's such a good mix between Sirius and Lily and Lupin as well as his own thing. It's only a snippet... But goddamn was it well done.


More Creators