DN Reacts
patreon
How I Met Your Mother S4 E5 - Shelter Island (Cut Reaction)
🕑 Added 2026-01-27 16:11:13 +0000 UTCComments
Amanda Peters
The movie Shutter Island came out two years after this episode aired. It’s called Shelter Island because they are literally on Shelter Island in this episode ;)
Michael Burke
I didn’t see the twist here coming, but in retrospect, they certainly dropped some hints, such as someone still living in the apartment upstairs, the kids not being blonde, the fact that the show is “how I met your mother,” not “how I married your mother,” meaning the story would have ended with Ted going to get his tattoo removal done if Stella was the mother, and others.
Sasha
Immediately clickung watch! One of the best episodes that show the signature storytelling skills of this show!
