RunFaps
MagnusGrey
MagnusGrey patreon

[Skill-Eater 2] Chapter 50: Passing Grade

🕑 Added 2025-03-17 17:00:11 +0000 UTC

Comments

Bryan Dickerson

Hey thanks. I really appreciate the feedback, I'll see about tweaking the scene right now

Robert McCarter

This REALLY felt off to me. Last chapter: "to be annoyed that the man was willing to let them walk into a trap." A trap so bad that "you would have taken some significant burns.” Also, "He took off his toolbelt and backpack so they wouldn’t get caught in the blasts," His toolbelt is REALLY important to him, and while Edge has regeneration, his two teammates that would also have been badly burned don't. Indeed, he has to "stoically endure the pain of his wounds". It seemed to me you were leading us to at least a small confrontation between Edge and Snake, because Snake was perfectly willing to let them all be badly burned, and have their gear destroyed. But all we get is, a lame "By now, Edge had changed his mind about Snake’s personality". WHAT?! WTAF? That's it? Snake let them almost get really badly burned when both of them KNEW about the fire, and all we get is a "Edge had changed his mind"?!!! I completely understand if you don't want to drag out simmering tension between the two of them, but this felt really weird, like Edge was willing to just let Snake walk all over them. This is a a big - disappointing - character point for Edge, to just so easily accept being treated so callously. By not dealing with this in more detail, you're telling us a lot about Edge's personality, in a bad way. I'm also REALLY surprised that neither Jumo nor Mel said anything either, just quietly accept the pointers and move on?! None of this makes sense with what we know about them - especially Mel. It really feels like you're not being true to your characters. It is really odd to me that you can spend chapters discussing walking across the plains to the dungeon, chapters getting ready to enter the dungeon, chapters entering the dungeon, but then gloss over something so important between characters. I hope you don't mind my feedback.

Robert McCarter

"All the clearing", i think should be "clearings"


More Creators