RunFaps
Honour Rae
Honour Rae patreon

ATS B5 Ch41: The Thick of Battle

🕑 Added 2025-01-25 03:24:20 +0000 UTC

Comments

killer

Because you can compare this to other eruptions, we have read about both a rare and legendary eruption, and this eruption has spawned many rares, compared to the rare eruption which only had 1, this is closer to the legendary one, also it’s heavily implied by honour Rae that this is a legendary eruption, hell it’s confirmed in the newest chapter.

Cion Distan

Same same. Considering the audio book is set to come out in less than TWO MONTHS, I'd have to imagine they already have the rest of book 5 written and are working on last minute editing while it's being recorded right now. I imagine recording it and editing it and all that takes time. But like you said, ultimately it's about supporting an indie author.

Dawn Walker

I remember when I signed up, we were promised three chapters a week. I hope the writer is working on several chapters and doing some editing so that we can receive multiple chapters at once. I understand that writing takes a lot of time, and we all get busy with life. However, it can be frustrating when someone says they will do something and then doesn't follow through. I understand that it’s only $5, but honestly, I could wait until the book is published and pay a credit on Audible for less than what I’m contributing to the writer here. I want to support young writers, but I also don't like feeling as if I'm being taken advantage of.

Cion Distan

There would be a huge delay between chapters as soon as I sub lol xD I check twice a day just to make sure

James Donnelly

I can't follow your logic about the eruption. Why are the legendaries coming?

killer

I like how whenever it's Arthur getting a card from his set the cover has cool colors, while when it's brix's it's black and red. Also I think by the cover of book 5 it's somewhat confirmed that the blood guy, and dragon probably has his card, or something, and if that's the case then it confirms that this eruption is legendary, and at least one legendary pair is going to die.

Antony Claughton

I make it 5. One as a kid where he saw the dragon assassinated, one during Brix’s trials, one where he led the trainee wing (disastrously), and two at Blood Moon. Dragon riders see heaps. There are multiple old dragons, and there is an eruption every week or so. Even when it was less frequent it was surely over a dozen a year.

James Donnelly

She doesn't need more defenses. She already has 2 shield cards. Giving her a 3rd is wasting it when someone else that doesn't have any defenses could use it. Giving it to her would be a mismanagement of resources. Putting a hat on a hat so to speak.

killer

I agree with not giving her more stuff, but also she can’t really do anything yet, she’s an attacker but she can’t go out because her dragon is a baby, and if she dies so does equinox from the backlash, also when equinox gets old enough they will be by the strongest no matter the time of day, because Sams and Horatio get way strong and weaker depending on the time, imagine how weak they are in the winter where there is only a few hours of daylight. But seriously she is super annoying and it’s not excusable because she’ll be strong, or is young, because the rest of the retinue is only a year or 2 older than her.

killer

He um already took it last chapter, I think, but honestly it’s way more suited for horatio and sams, since it’s light based, and they really need an actual stealth card, the void one is good, but it’s absolutely not a stealth card

killer

Core of permafrost would also fit with cresilda, and honestly she gets the least amount of stuff out his retinue. But seriously it fits her too well to not give her, it’s another super defensive shield, that probably harms the attacker since it’s so cold, and she is the most elementally diverse fighter, and defender in the retinue.

killer

Not even his fifth, but you also got to realize that not many people survive 1, even dragon riders, and he’s a legendary, they only go out for the the absolute worse eruptions, right before the king destroys the land.

James Donnelly

For the love of lava, lava whip and whatever her joint card is.

Prakash Alagarsamy

Can anyone tell what cards soledad has?

killer

Honour Rae is obviously setting up a legendary eruption, it has many mega-scourgings and it just started spouting them out, which is unlikely for a rare eruption, and it’s massive, all foreshadowing it being legendary, hell Arther straight up said himself that he thinks that it’s legendary, he kept on asking why the legendary pairs haven’t shown up yet, they only show up for extremely power rares, or legendaries. And Whitaker is a legendary, and considering all the foreshadowing he’s about to show up to the eruption, and why would he ignore his legendary second in command, that he has been stalking using seers? It’s not like Arther and Brix can hide who they are, especially when they’re fighting legendaries.

James Donnelly

It's borderline irresponsible for Arthur to not have that time card in his heart. The amount of times it would have come in handy solely in this eruption is huge. Countless lives could have been saved

Reno

Awesome chapter, and quite long too. 🤩 Thank you! I wonder if Arthur knows that windburn is really just a sunburn in cold weather, when people think they don't need to wear sunscreen. And if sunscreen exists.

Kris Piskorski

Soledad and equinox will be overpowered af when they grow up a bit!

Antony Claughton

So what have the legendary dragons been doing during the battle? Also, odd for Arthur to act like he’s seen many eruptions. Isn’t this just his 5th, with two being entirely from the ground?

SM

I agree, something needs to get eaten during this battle & what better than a card. I'm sure brix would agree!

SM

If liquid inferno is given to a dragon the "not" shouldn't matter as much. You'd expect fire breathing creatures to be at least resistant to lighting themselves up! I agree with killer that removing "nearly" would turn that rare into a legendary card.

Decide

I Wonder if Flame Shrapnel could be used with the nightmare flames, this increasing its area of effect.

James Donnelly

IMO soledad is extremely unlikeable. She borderline forced her way on to the retinue, and has only taken things without adding any value to the team. I hate the idea of giving her more cards without making her earn them.

Sharrif

@Lux: Penn’s card is Master of Combat. Arthur currently has Master of Skills, Master of Body, and Master of Cards.

James Donnelly

It seems kind of redundant to just keep giving her shields. It would be way better to give it to someone that doesn't have defenses.

James Donnelly

Liquid Inferno and the Mana card should go to Soledad, even though I hate how she has not had to earn anything she has gotten. Both will help her with her lava cards. Since neither one unlock mana or create fire themselves. Flame Shrapnel would work great for Cressida's bears. Veil of Ice should go to Sams and Horatio since it works for 2, is partly light based and they don't have any stealth abilities. Core of the Permafrost shield, is a card Arthur should keep. If you are not going to have strong offenses, you might as well have strong defenses.

Salvo

Veil of ice is probably the best combo with brixaby’s call of the void we have seen yet: he needs to get into melee range to take the card! I would like to know if it works against UV and infrared light as well.

Blackjack

Im curious where the time card went. I thought he should've been put that card in

Jessica Hussey

But I get the feeling one of them will eat it.

Jessica Hussey

I think that Cress should get the shield. Maybe he could make it have synergy with her other shields.

Antony Claughton

Why would he fight a legendary? Or confront Whitaker next chapter?

Antony Claughton

I don’t think it stops him getting combat skills via normal means (lessons & training), it just doesn’t boost them.

killer

I can’t wait until next chapter, we’ll finally see how brix and arther will fight a legendary, find out how many legendaries there are, and have a confrontation with Whitaker, and that one guy who’s in charge of blood moon, also new legendary card, and we’re getting close to the climax, or resolution, and see what brix’s next card does

Lux Theris

True. He could learn some hand to hand combat and grind a few more skills. But I'm not sure if the other card on his causing heart deck would stop him from getting those skills as it is combat. Thought, to be honest I don't really remember what "master of" is his card. Was it weapons or combat? I really don't remember

killer

I don’t think he can do most of that maybe the first one, but the second one would probably make it a legendary card considering that it doesn’t use mana, but either way he would need to get his card smithing skill to probably around the 50’s for most of those

killer

I mean master f body enhancement has a lot of combat potential, same with master of skills, especially with edge cases, but especially body enhancements, he’s been neglecting his skills, and has honestly been unimaginative, as said by everyone right before they had entered the dark heart

CasStocks

As mentioned last chapter, I’m also a bit nervous about Soledad getting too many things given to her (after the challenge cards and the egg, plus how she defined herself as the “only true” combat rider). I get that pair needs at least one or two of the new cards but would love if Cressida got the flame shrapnel card to use with her bears. If Arthur/Brix don’t want the ice invisibility it could be beneficial to give it to horatio/Sam who don’t have stealth cards as it deals with reflecting light. Lastly, it would be nice to see Soledad do something for the team by giving a card she earns/found/won that isn’t compatible to her to another member of the retinue (ideally Joy to indirectly mend Soledad’s relationship to Cressida and I feel like joy is lacking some power of the original 3 rider/dragon pairs, but marion and his dragon could work too). Thanks for the chapter, love the updates as always!

Dani Sarah Sperry

Wow! A lot happening in that chapter! Can’t wait for the next

Remy Gramont

Tftc

Lux Theris

While I do agree a full utility build can sometimes be overpowered (I played rpg with a character filled with utility skills and he could go on a 1v1 easily). Arthur's current cards don't give him that much versatility to do actual combat. He should or look for more utility cards that can bridge that gap, or he need a specialized combat card. And he needs to stuff that time card on his heart deck before it burns a hole on his pockets

GloryHound

Already see card smithing potential here: Liquid Inferno - move the "not" from the 3rd sentence to 4th sentence so weilder is impervious to fire and 'may "not" be smothered'. Core of the Permafrost Shield - delete the world "nearly" Veil of ice - delete "one" and make companion plural, delete "less" and update "low" to "all"


More Creators