zen33n patreon

【NOVEMBER 2021】POLLS

🕑 Added 2021-10-27 17:35:38 +0000 UTC

Comments

Arimil

It's not like Genshin characters were specifically chosen, it was a lottery with crowd sourced suggestions. Although I do agree that characters that not only won the previous poll but got first place shouldn't be in the running the following month.

Arimil

Can we move away from VTubers? (funnily enough none of them showed up this round)

Ciel

Those are very sensible rules - solves most of the problems while avoiding too much additional complexity (votes carrying over is too complex imo). If we're limiting to one character per franchise, the number of total characters in every poll should be reduced as well (probably to when ZeN33n was picking them, so 12 instead of 24). Character wheel can still be used to pick the first character from each franchise. Under this model I think you can continue to let each person vote for as many characters they want.

HomuChanFan

The votes carrying over sounds interesting. Personally I’d just like some simple rules; one character per franchise, franchise who’s character wins cannot be in next month’s poll, and one vote each person.

Ciel

One method I've seen: vote results carry over from month to month and the artist draws the top 3 after each polling period and removes them from the tally. This is cool because no votes are ever "wasted". Adds more complexity though since it's tracked outside of Patreon though Google Sheets. I think this and/or restrictions on characters after winning would even the playing field, especially for under-represented/non-gacha characters.

HomuChanFan

There rly needs to be some restrictions. Why is Elaina on here again after just winning last month? And I love the genshin girls too but there doesn’t need to be 3 to pick from in a poll. There’s already plenty of porn of all of them anyways. There’s some great choices on here that will never get picked otherwise. Makes me not care to stay subbed honestly.

Ferdinand Nabelkrieg

and some form of loser bracket

Ciel

Is it possible to temporarily remove characters who are drawn this month from the character wheel pool in the following month? They'd be eligible again 2 polls after their last win. This would help with character variety between two consecutive months.