RunFaps
Magic_Smithing
Magic_Smithing patreon

Cp: Chapter 2 A Not So Champion's Return Home

🕑 Added 2022-02-19 02:06:47 +0000 UTC

Comments

Dave

Between both storys you fail at painting a picture in words of the larger world the story is based in but detail the little things amd comunications between characters and their feelings in excruciating detail if you making a new story have the mc as someone everyone visits and tell their story, bar in a local town, a healer, a resturant, vet, merchant, tailor this will keep the world small and focused and suit how little you focus on the MC as the story progresses pokemon fan fiction wont allow you to do that I really doubt you can make this to 30 chapters before loosing the idea.

HardhatDoozer

Well I think I won’t be really into it until the two main characters are united. But like others I’d be concerned about Patreon doing an audit of your account. If you at least rename it and take out the fan part of the title you would be safer I think.

Imspinnennetz

Look at the post title New Story Idea

Wolfzero7

Where’s chapter 1

Daniel

That was a bit of a slog to read through. I think most of this information would have been better presented during an emotional back and forth between Sarah and her family closer to the point she`s ready to travel again rather than an info dump that has no dramatic tension well before it's entirely relevant.

Alex C

Enjoying it

PaperMache7

Way too much infordumping before it's relevant

Rairarku

I like it - looking forward to more, personally. I also recommend looking deeper into copyright, but I don't know squat about it myself.

Straven

Style's good, smooth read throughout the chapter. Lots of bits of world building already making things slightly squared away in my mind of what's what. Honestly wondering if our first character actually is a legendary or not, next would be if he's known or an entirely new one never before seen. Both points have me very curious and looking foreword to more once in a while. Thank you very much for the chapter. Oh and looking at some other comments.......I'd agree with finding otu more about copy issues, this isn't the first time I've read stuff about a certain company being 'extremely anal' about going after any and all that even slightly sound like them. Also explains why I've only ever found the occasional attempt at writing anything like pokemon with the authors stopping within 1-5 chapters or less and then vanishing.

Thundermike00

Will pokemon be able to die in your novel or are you keeping things pg-13?

Michael McLeod

thanks for the chapter, i look forward to the next one

Vladerag

To be clear, if you wanted to do this without having any issue with copyright, you would need to completely change the names of everything and those names can't be easily mistaken for the original. So you can absolutely have a story about people taming monsters that they carry around with them and fight with, but you can't have a story about someone becoming a zubat. Tbh, if this was any other company besides Nintendo, I wouldn't worry. Nintendo, however, is zealous in defending their copyright, very litigous, and keep in mind that they might very well sue you under international laws or in Japan. You could go nuts writing about Blizzard's properties and they wouldn't care at all whereas Nintendo has been known to sue over ROM hacks. Although, there also is a very large chance that they never notice at all.

Vladerag

Um, Id suggest you reread the copyright stuff again because, well no, sadly. Pokemon regions and Pokemon are the copyright of Game Freak and Nintendo. An otherwise entirely original story about Pokemon in a region is a definite violation of their copyright. Edit: I hate patreons layout, and cant figure out how the heck im supposed to hyperlink so you get this longform, sorry: https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html#:~:text=Fair%20use%20is%20a%20legal,protected%20works%20in%20certain%20circumstances.&text=Nature%20of%20the%20copyrighted%20work,purpose%20of%20encouraging%20creative%20expression.


More Creators