RunFaps
Magic_Smithing
Magic_Smithing patreon

New Story Idea

🕑 Added 2022-02-11 06:31:32 +0000 UTC

Comments

tcecrog

I advise you to not do a fanfiction of Pokémon. There are a lot of them, you are limited on the creativity of the original source, and you can't make a profit off it since it is copyrighted. You do have a great introduction, but when the story turned to Pokémon, I lost interest in the story. Now, I do like a reincarnated as a monster story, but even more so is monsters that you create. A new monster gives readers a mystery of what your character needs to live, grow, and defend themselves and more so in a universe of monster that can threaten them. This is one reason why I like Magic-Smithing with farkas, karhus, and chameleon spiders, and who knows what else is in that forest. I think you would have a better time writing a world with original monsters, than rely on Pokémon.

Straven

Finally got around to reading this one and taking a look, sorry I didn't get to it sooner as I checked out the story you mention and for that I both hate/love you...read the entire damn thing and the other story in under 24 hours and lost 3/4's of my sleep since I kept on reading through the night without realizing it till much later in the morning! Honestly this looks very interesting to me, good chance of solid mature characters through so far hence good chance of it staying that way later on. Nice flow to me at least, good base and I'm very very curious what type he's turned out to be, knew it couldn't be certain ones I'm aware of from the older versions I've actually played due to certain characteristics he had so I hope to learn more in time. Thanks for the story and yes I did enjoy reading it quite a bit.

Dave

God no please no!!!, magic smithing is original idea very rare mix of metal work and magic creativity rare MC, Family slice of life mixed in .... change to Pokemon story couldnt be more generic and unoriginal, lots or writters have a second story to pull themselgs out of one world and into another to help perspective and it can work well, fantasy, creativity, adventure, slice of life, village life, stats build, magic, mother complex, minning and no dungeons basically what I am saying is I dont see a reason to support something so generic.

Jonathan

throwing down one of the cars in his hand Just how strong do you have to be to play with this Uno deck? cars -> cards. :P needles to say flood warnings were issued needless making an already beautiful sight all that grander. making an already beautiful sight that much grander. Stop codling the boy coddling (codling is a baby codfish) David got his piolets license recently pilot's experiencing Engen problems; experiencing engine problems; He twisted and turned, trashing about, thrashing Groaning to himself, Ryan slowly turned his enormous head, so his face was no longer buried in the dusty cave floor. But as Ryan shifts his larger than normal head, he can't keep his heartbeat from skyrocketing even further as he glances at what used to be his left arm. The leather wing looks like something a bat would have, and that isn't even touching on the fact that it's two shades of purple. Switched to present tense mid-paragraph. Then, trying to flex what was once his fingers, were once Alright, I can work with this, Ryan tells himself, trying and failing to get a hold of his emotions. Finally, managing to angle his nails against the ground, he pushes with all his might, carefully flipping himself over onto his back. present tense again and when it was reduced to half of what it started as it stopped feeding into his wails, and when it was reduced to half of what it started, it stopped feeding into his wails, Fearing he might have caused some sort of cave-in, Ryan tries to scramble back to his feet, only for his new body to refuse to move as he wanted it to. present tense bank had ever been robed, robbed the three rock Pokémon skid to a sudden stop at the abrupt shout, but he was too scared to glance up at the three Pokémon that were surely standing right in front of him, lest he accidentally angers them more present tense it would help them worm up to the baby warm up

Carl Mason

I just want into it this morning when I saw it come up so I will give it more of a read this evening. Pertaining to the general description, I am not a lover of fanfiction (I can't stand the corruption of known canon, and that almost always happens), and I was never crazy about Pokémon to begin with. Getting around that is if the story is original enough or detached from the rest of the canonical world it is usually okay. I would second (or maybe third) what others have said and make it a similar concept but not make it Pokémon. Original characters, original story, and please, if you do start this, don't allow yourself to fall into the trap so many other fanfic writers do: don't expect readers to have basic knowledge of your world, based on canon. "Oh, no, it is a Burstcano! Now we are in trouble!" Who the f**k is Burstcano? What does he look like, what are his abilities, don't fall into that clearly marked pit trap. Please. Again, I will actually read it later and offer feedback on the concept/story itself.

Vladerag

Personally? I'd avoid doing this, if I were you. Nintendo is notoriously copyright UNfriendly and this wouldn't pass a Fair Use test if it was in front of a court. Sure, they often don't care about fanfiction, but anything that can make money - even if it is Youtube Let's Plays - are torn down immediately. Having said all of that and leaving it aside, I am personally thinking that what I already know about Pokemon will conflict with what you write. That dissonance will probably make reading this somewhat uncomfortable. Not to mention the fact that Gamefreak and Nintendo have been quietly sidestepping massive ethical issues in the Pokemon universe for decades and if you really wanted to write a lot in that universe you would eventually have to address them. So unless you are open to going into things like slavery, dogfighting, kidnapping and general animal abuse, then things are going to become very difficult, very fast. Plus, the whole thing is a minefield. This is, what, an AU/OC fic? If you have any named characters die, then we've got Character Death too. That is basically the three most controversial fanfic tags there are and you can expect one of two things: 1) no one ever reads this or 2) everyone reads this and your comment sections turn into warzones comparable to ww1. Complete with trenches, toxic gas, and flames.

Saerthas

Most pokemon storys are Bad cringy things with Team rocken and all the weird caracters etc in it

Saerthas

I agree with David I would love a pokemon Story that can stand on it's own

Alex C

Really liked it

Derun

Withholding judgement on the story for now. I haven't read much fan fiction before, but I feel like the nostalgia factor from knowing pokemon will clash with changes you make (i.e. you move away from the anime/games and it stops being what people once knew). May have more success by doing something inspired by pokemon so that you can make your own system without having a knee jerk reaction from people who expect to see what they know. Feels like you're moving in that direction with having this character a bat-like pokemon without being a known entity. Just my 2¢

mpop

Not my thing

Guilherme Silva

Not bad, but I am not too interested in fan fiction. (Didn't love Borne of Creation either). Besides, be careful with copyright, Nintendo is a bitch.

Alex Galaitsis

I’m not really interested in Pokémon, although I imagine many others would be. Like others have said, I’m not sure how it would work to post it on Patreon for money but maybe it would? We’re technically donating, not buying?

Jonathan Grant

I don't read fanfic

Rairarku

Well we've just started, I am not gonna be saying any option of ues or no. I think an entire full-fledged story would be enough to judge with, no? Jokes aside, I would like more, because I'm a sucker for Pokémon, and we could use more to judge with.

Osamaru Ta

/o/ I second the [Borne of Caution] recommendation! Its one of the few Pokemon Fanfics that's managed to do it well. Its like another Pokemon Generations/Evolutions.

Mezo

I will give it a chance I would just say make it Pokemon inspired not a fan fiction. Like you can totally ape all of Pokemons shit just use different names and slightly different designs in description. It will be better for you legally and financially in the future.

Bable Zmith

Good Job Dude, very compelling as Bliss said. Not particularly a Pokemon fan, but your skill shines through. Loved the first part of the chapter, second part was confusing, scary and loud. Oh right, birth is like that. 8D

BlissForgotten

I really like it. I like magic smithing and am quite hopeful you continue this but Borne of Caution is delightful and I would be more than happy to keep my subscription if you start this new story too. You're one of my favorite patreon authors because you make memorable characters, and great scenes and interactions for them. Just take my money and make good stuff, whatever it is.

Jackson Ragland

If it feels good to you kosnik go for it, I'll give it a shot but there's a high chance I will not be along for the ride. I think that writers creative juices flowing is under appreciated so i can respect writing another story

Thundermike00

Oh boy, I know where this is going. You got tired of writing magic-smithing didn’t you? If you decide to go through with this, this new story idea. I bet you are going to at first start off slow, but then gain traction and start focusing more on the new story instead of the other story that all your fans here have been waiting for. Then you are going to either put magic smithing on hold, or you are going to slow down the release of magic smithing and disappoint many people. But hey bud it’s your choice, just live with the consequences.

PaperMache7

The story is nice, though like others have mentioned monetization of fanfiction is iffy. Also what Pokemon is he?

Michael McLeod

to the naysayers, if your going to say no please say why you don't care for fanfics, if its because of some relative creativity restriction, then the pokemon world is almost as malleable a world as minecraft in creative mode when it comes to world shaping the only complaint i've ever really had with pokemon journey fanfics is that many authors don't plan well enough or are not committed enough to finishing the story, serious irl stuff aside there are just way to many promising starts to stories where the author just vanishes with no warning, something this particular theoretical story should be safe from because pateron authors in general tend to be mare communicative with readers

Qwokka

Sorry buddy, I am not really a fan of fan fics or Pokemon etc. , but it is not bad though (written).

Alphafenrir401

Honestly not a bad idea but I'd recommend remove the pokemon references changes names on stuff. pokemon inspired is ok but avoid it being a fan fiction make it it's own thing add your own twists. You can totally do a pokemon style without the need to use pokemon stuff people will get where the inspiration came from

Michael McLeod

I don't know how the money stuff would work either but as apposed to the other commentors as of this post I'm all for this story while it is true that there are a lot of fanfictions out there that can become cookiecutter like, a new trainer journey is a ball of raw potential and with how you've done with Magic-Smithing i look forward to seeing what you would do for your own spin on a pokemon journey

Marcus Martin

I am not a fan of fan fic.

Seth

First, be careful with fan fiction, idk how it works because pattern is donation based, but it might be able to be copyright strikes or something along those lines. Secondly, I’ve never really been a fan of fan fiction so i doubt I would stay a patron for just this story, I’ll give it a try at some point, but if you end up giving up on Magical smithing and only have this story im probably gone. Thirdly, I don’t mind more than one story, but again im not a fan of fan fiction, but if you had another original story im sure I would be willing to give it a better shot than this one.

Tyler Shepherd

I’m sorry but I’m not a fan


More Creators