RunFaps
Magic_Smithing
Magic_Smithing patreon

Ch: 99

🕑 Added 2021-05-17 07:48:34 +0000 UTC

Comments

Bettina

Thanks for the chapter. For the editing pot: "While talking to Sandra, I removing the kaglese arrow" -> removed " I want to hear everything before you show me what you learned tomorrow." -> yesterday? "I smile in triumphant" -> triumph "how the enchantments fair on steel." -> fare

Timo Immig

According to RR last active he is alive on there. On here no clue. Roughly 18 days of silence.

austin kutz

Yo, you alive? Been some time

Eric Gonyea

I agree you are awesome you are also entitled to take a break and have writer's block. But I'm starting to get frustrated because for the money we pay you what you owe us is transparency. I don't care if I only get one chapter a month or two for the next year but I want to know about it and not feel like we are being ignored. Seriously don't let this story die you are an amazing author but either you need to work on communication or hire someone. If I don't hear from you within the next week just to let us know you're still alive I'm canceling as well.

Chemnerd263

I know nothing about writing, but you're doing great, even if you do have a block right now. Take care of yourself, brainstorm a few chapters ahead. Find someone you can bounce ideas with to get past this bump. You're awesome, and you should feel awesome.

HyeoJ

Every chiil the fck out, holy fck. You guys honestly don't know how hard it is to write so stfu. all we can do is give the writer all our support and let him/her take their time.

Timo Immig

He doesn't help himself by saying that he tries to keep a five day schedule and then doesn't follow that 3 times in a row with 2 double time and the next chapter has already taken three times as long of a wait. If he doesn't want to be reminded then he shouldn't ''promise'' deadlines that he might not keep. Partially it's his own words that created the "conditoning".

mudokon

This comment section is a shitshow 😂, but i kinda understand the critism. You conditioned your supporters with regular updates and delay notices, that this sudden silence is giving wrong impresion. I do not support writters on patreon for x amount of chapters per month, but most probably do, so take my stupid 5$, have a beer on me and calmly think about the future of this story. I think you should restructure the tiers and tear down the pay walls when you cannot deliver the promises. Unlock everything for smaller price with achiavable goal (1chp/month) and if someone wants to really support you, they will give you more. I think thats fair to everyone and hopefully will elevate the pressure you feel. Worklife balance is very important and sarisfy those who feel like you robbing them. Take care brother and get better.

Emanuel Sla

bye

Zap

Love the story please don't let it die

Toni Pampliega

Really sorry to have to cancel the membership. I hope this is a phase an the story continues and I can come back to support it, if it has regular content. As all the patreons, I love the story. But one month with only one realease... too much. Stay safe Kosnik4!

Stephen

I've paused my membership but will gladly sign up again if you get things back under control. I wish you nothing but the best and hope you find your groove again. I love this story and hope you get your house in order.

D

Hiho, i do not disagree completely. I wrote a comment not long ago about people losing their job because of mental health issues - and said that this is his job and he is in danger to lose it if he keeps going this way. Meaning, i disagree on the fact that people with mental health issues can work just fine and in no danger to lose their job if they just keep trying.

Camelopardalis

You’re assuming arrogance. Plenty of people freeze under negative feedback, and the success of this story might inspire feelings of unworthiness. I just hope the author levels his Meditation skill and learns to deal with this. The more successful you are, the more cantankerous fans will find you. I hope he doesn’t wind up like Rothfus or Martin, abandoning a promising story.

Hamed Al-Ghamdi

Alot of people here are talking about the "entitled" people writing how they're not satisfied, and condemning them for expressing their opinions. You need to understand something, this writer did NOT take this whole thing seriously, for some reason he just took the money but not the JOB and it is a freaking job, when you are being paid more than 100k a year to write, you better be so serious about it. You better sit yourself on your PC for 8 hours or more and I don't care if all you do is stare at the keyboard, because if you stare long enough you will put a couple of words in, and the rest will drag itself will them. This is not a muse thing where you would only write when inspiration hits you (that ship has long sailed when you accepted money by implying that you would make this your main focus as a JOB). Now people would start defending the writer and asking me how do I know that he's not doing just that but nothing good is been put down on paper, well, that could be the case if the author put on a couple of chapters and they came in bad, but that's not the case, especially with this wall of silence. For those who would say something about mental health issues I would say 'really'? I worked my whole adult life and I've seen people with all kinds of Severe mental issues and every day I would see them sit next to me from 9 to 5 and preform so freaking beautifully at what they do, because they understand how important it is to thier lives to put in the work, so yeah. How I really see this ? I see that the author got comfortable and still thinks that people won't stop supporting him if he doesn't take this seriously ( especially when he's being validated in the comments ). Ps if the author does what some people here think he will do and gets a chapter at the beginning of next month... you know what that would mean? Right? (If you don't reread this shitty comment again)

Desurtfawks

Edge lords so sharp you can cut yourself on the comments. Kos catch you later bro. I know you will be back but until then.

John Koor

He's continuing to post updates on royal road, just not here.

Straven

I don't mind waiting especially for such a great read, what I don't like though is dead silence esp after hearing he got a shot I know has had some unhappy affects and results on many people. I'd be happy simply hearing he's alive and kicking.

Stephen Pearson

Fwiw, I don't think that means anything anymore; either a bug or privacy change seems to return that for anyone whose name is clicked on. Shame, since you could sometimes find good stories from likeminded people's subscriptions.

Melnik5

Take your time, write out a good outline on where you want the story to go. DONT rush. A lot of stories that i read fell apart whenever the author rushed. Don’t make that mistake and destroy your story. We can wait

Rip Woodham

It's funny how blind to irony you are. You find this comment section and immediately start lambasting a bunch of people who are holding the author to *his words.* Spamming the same comment "Retarded and unnecessary comment ..." and not even realizing how accurately that describes your own actions. I think you need to look up what an insult is, because few if any have attacked Kosnik personally here. And yet, in all these over 120 comments I don't think anybody has been as insultory as you.

White Neko Knight

Damn, there's a lot of rather rude and self-entitled individuals in the comments. Do what it takes to make sure you feel healthy Kosnik, I'm staying subbed.

Camelopardalis

“ This patron isn’t supporting any creators at the moment.”

Bobtur

Retarded and unnecessary comment ... so are you !

Bobtur

Retarded and unnecessary comment ...

Bobtur

What is wrong with all of you people insulting him ? What are you ? 15 and spending your "precious" money on this story but don't get anything to eat ? I follow authors that published twice in a year and never complained about it. What is wrong with all of you people yelling that "X dollars is too much for X chapters a month" ? Being a patreon is all about being supportive. You are technically not owed anything for it, scumbags ! You do realise you can support on patreon creators that don't publish anything, right ? Or are you too entitled for that ? So fuck you all of you, and see you next month ... or not, becuz' all the retards will have left by now.

SilentStriker

I hope everything is okay. Everyone needs a vacation every now and then.

Hauke

I love the Story. I will be back once there are regular updates again. Take the time you need and get professional help. Had to do so too in the past and it is simply a good decision. I wish you all the best ❣️

I also do so. At this point though, I'm wondering if there's any point in coming back. The story is great, I adore it, but 2 chapters per month? By the time it builds up to 110 or so, I'll have lost interest.

Derrick McDowell

I

Andar

For a lot of reasons I usually alternate between one month of subscription and one or two months without, allowing chapters to collect before subscribing again. So next month you won't see me. If I return will completely depend on whether you manage to get more writing time in again in the future - I'll probably subscribe again when chapter 110 or 115 or so is on Patreon.

D

<b>*chuckles*</b> I beat he'll release one at the first of july when all the bad people with their bad comments have stopped subscribing. At least that's what i'm hoping for, because id feel bad if something bad had happened to him and all people like me could do was rage quit. <b>@kosnik</b> I really hope you just avoid our increasingly toxic comments and you do well. Wont see you next month, but i'm following so ill see if you're back and well. Maybe write your explanation in an open post so ex-followers can read it too?

FancyPantsu

Sorry Kosnik, but I'm not re-subbing. Get your shit together.

Dave

So Kosnik4 when are we getting a refund for this month , the whole idea of this process is you submit your writing on royal road (which is still being updated once a week) gain a fan base, put the lead chapters onto patron to earn cash to write the story and get to stop your full time/ part time work to concentrate on writing the story then publish the book in the end. If your gonna be a dick and no even tell all your supporters WTF is going on or provide any kind of content accepting our money is just f'ing rude

gattala

Dude im out, the author just destroyed my excitement with this story, good luck in your work and i hope you can find the chance to fix your communication problems.

Bookman

I think Kosniks mistake was that he published the story before creating an outline for it. He himself sayed that in his head the story only went this far and he is out of ideas. Usaly Authors have a rough outline or scetch of the story from start to finish so there is always a direktion to go to. Not having one ended more then a couple web series pre mature. I can only recomend to kosnik4 to do redo the entire story as a rough outline for now. Cancel Pantreon and just try to find yourself again. The Mark of a great person is now how much they can take. Its how quick they get back on their feet when life knocks you down. To keep going when the going gets tough.

Justin

Agree with the feedback. Kosnik has done an excellent job of writing, storytelling, and capturing a great fantasy setting. I hope you are doing ok and get your mojo back. I look forward to reading your amazing story once you get through the current challenges you are facing.

Timo Immig

You have 2 days otherwise you will only have writen 2 CHAPTERS in 1 MONTH. It is not 3 days, because of timezones.

John Scott

Multiple 10+ day gaps is hard to swallow, but the communication blackout is over the top. I hope this one doesn’t die, but in the mean time I’ll look elsewhere

Hugo Lallo

Still nothing huh?

Oblivious

✌️

Robert Mullins

Canceling. If by some miracle this story is back on again in a few months I'll consider trying again.

Tom Henman

Hated to do it but canceled my support here. Far too slow of releases and no contact/info from author on why.

Thaldor

I’m out for a while. Good luck with your writers block.

Melnik5

I love the story, but where is the next chapter

D

You must be joking. Did you take a look at the patreon counter? Even with him behaving that way, people still subscribe. xD But personally ill take a break, its not like the story runs away if i continue later when kosnik has returned to his former... form. ^^

Rip Woodham

It's seeming like if you want Kosnik to receive your criticism, you're going to have to criticize with your wallet.

Emanuel Sla

i love this hystory, but why you wasn´t posted chap by 10 days?

Camelopardalis

Kosnik4- We’re used to fantasy authors having difficulty finishing a story, but it is great when you check in. Plotting the middle of a story is difficult, and plenty of promising stories have been abandoned on Royal Road. But web serials allow a lot of leeway for fluff chapters, and you are due a few. You are a talented writer with a fresh perspective and a gift for creating a world into which readers can escape. You are making more in a month than many authors make from their first contract for an entire book with a traditional publisher. I hope you can own your success, and aren’t sabotaging yourself. If you worry you might be, you might Google “success thermostat.”

Sheeprat

sad to see a good story die

Desurtfawks

"consider myself an avid mastibator" TMI bro

George Watermelon

See ya on August or September, Kosnik, I need to recharge my batteries of hope. At that moment it's not even about money, but general negative uncertainty and lack of communication

Max Kendall

Sad to say that I will no longer be a patron after this month. I understand writers block and also things happening in one's personal life, but the complete lack of communication makes it difficult for me to want to continue supporting this series. I love the world that's being built and perhaps I will come back at some point, but for now I shall be saying goodbye.

Timo Immig

3 chapters a month at the current rate of a Chapter every 10 days.

Elsie Nnaji

Woow

Elsie Nnaji

$7 for just two chapters a month

Elsie Nnaji

No chapter today? From two chapters a week to one.. are u canceling Patreon.. please let us know

Emanuel Sla

I undestend the referenci.

Dave

Hmm 41 words per min is the global typing speed average, 5000 words is less than 2.5 hours or 10 percent of one day, now I consider myself an avid mastibator but still can't figure out what Kosnik does with the rest of the time?. At $4k a post you can afford an editor or an supportive writter I will be happy to come back and support you again when your actually supplying the work.please don't fail this story

George Watermelon

What do we say to the God of Updates? Not today!

Philip Pleiss

I need to stop cursing authors. Every time I sign up for an author's patreon, the author gets writing block or ends up taking tons of breaks. When I signed up for Vladerag the author just straight up stopped writing. When I bumped up my donation to Pirateaba, they cut their writing down from 8 chapters a month to 4 or 5.

Philip Pleiss

I'm curious if she could put the water purifying enchantment on the spigot of her smelting furnace, except swap the water rune for earth or metal. Would that filter out all the non earth attuned metal, or would that filter the slag, giving her ultra purity materials?

Timo Immig

Kosnik please inform when you are late. And try not to take 10 days again.

Timo Immig

Better not. Weapons of that precision and strength are more likely to kill their creator if anything goes wrong. After all the first guns regularly missfired or blew up injuring or killing their users. Something as powerfull and prescicion based as a Rail gun would be very dangerous. Furthermore a complex control circuit is likely a high tier rune. Otherwise with low level runes it is at most a one shot weapon as the runes will dissintegrate the weapon.

Timo Immig

Doesn't she need some instructions in order to use those?

Michael Weis

She should ask Silver Herd or Pacore for a runic healing item.

Michael Weis

Railgun. She should tell Pacore that she can make a weapon to kill the Dragon. All she needs are the right runes (electrical, cooling, insulation, circuitry/regulatory, capacitor, resistor, etc.) and materials (magic metals/stones, elemental beast material). Remember that lightning tree she encountered with her Dad? Could convince Silver Herd to invest in the weapon development so they can be paid BIG by Scholl or Pacore later.

Svish

She could do that, or get her master to give her the information... but that would shorten the story- so the author would not so it.

Michael Weis

Why hasn't she called Giovanni to buy out Sandra's magic contract on her behalf so she could learn magic from her?

Michael Weis

Me too. It would increase absorption of ambient mana when she spins it, and fly off (increase weight?) when she activates mana threads on the handle. And unleash an arcane electric shock (or expel arcane force) when it hits when activated with mana threads. But it would cost a lot of mana to recall unless it's soul-bound, something that doesn't exist or hasn't been mentioned yet. That feature might have to wait till she gets her hand on the soul mage journal.

Scott Fellman

I got phiser vaccine second shot had me out of work 3 days 2 of those with severe flu like symptoms 1 of those to recover from the other two and I'm still weezing and hacking 5 days in. But you know what they say progress

Bad Timing

They are still not in agreement on that. Aaliyah want them to stay in the village, while they want to follow.

Steven Palmer

I thought her parents said that they are going with her. So did that change? Or is she still just hoping for the best that they will not go?

Imspinnennetz

I don't think that Giovanni is going to shortchange Aaliyah. He after all decided to throw his company's future with Scholl for her and risk being branded as traitor. However, Kervin will have to make a new contract with Aaliyah.

HardhatDoozer

Loved the chapter. But since she ate the contract with Gray personally and he lent her the 450 gold worth of kaglese ore, she’s in for a pleasant surprise when she doesn’t have anyone to pay back for her work. An unintended consequence of his death right after the contract was eaten.

Dave

Really happy the focus is sticking with MC for these last few chapters, it's nice progress for her to learn how the mana pathways she makes in her metal creations can facilitate enchantment and I can see the progress getting there... slowly. 1 chapter every 10 days is supper slow hope you are keeping yourself active physically and keeping the happy endorphins pumping and not becoming a cave dweller

Imspinnennetz

Sandra is responsible for figuring out the step 4 of the enchanting ink. I think when she gives birth and is able to use her mana more freely, she will be more active in helping Aaliyah experiment on runes.

Ray Johnson

Sandra is really starting to feel like dead weight. We keep hearing about how much she has helped Aaliyah in progressing the ink, but it seems that Sandra is providing minimal support at best. More realistically she seems to be mooching off of Aaliyah’s natural talent and hard work.

Imspinnennetz

I don't think she owes 450 gold as such. The original deal was that the company (Grey) gave her 450 gold (Retail value) worth of material and would pay her at 70% of the final retail price of the weapons. I think what Kosnik wanted to write is that she is paid 168-280 gold for the spears and swords (Retail value for company is 5*80 = 400 gold). She should get another 210 gold for the arrows (Retail value for the company for the 6 arrows is 50*6 = 300 gold).

alex

I am confused by something. She owes 450 and expects 168-280. isnt the majority of what she owes is from the Kaglese ore that she used to make the weapons? At least 400 was from the Kaglese, so she LOST money smelting metal and forging them into weapons? If this is how valued her skills are why is she working as a blacksmith?

Imspinnennetz

I wonder if putting small piece of spider carapace into the flame during the enchanting ink making process will improve the enchanted ink's ability to absorb wind mana.

Timo Immig

I think there was a chapter that mentioned book presses or something like that.

brandy

woohoo, glad your alive. As for the story I think she needs to stop considering it impossible to figure out engraving, After all someone already figured it out once or it wouldn't exist. She is better off than the first person to figure it out. Still say she should try building some things from earth. Nothing major, but small things like a book press would change the world. Especially if enchantments could be mass produced.

Blake Richardson

Thanks for the chapter

Black Unicorn

I would do so if I was her, she's more a blacksmith then a fighter and even Pacore should see that from her arrow. If I was Pacore when she gets to Scholl I'd have train with the best blacksmiths in the country then the best enchanters with combat being a twice a week thing to get her able to fight well but not at the point it kills her obvious talent for crafting.

Black Unicorn

I'm sorry Kosnik I've had my second shot for over 3 weeks now and no extra arm's as of yet. On a more story based note nice work. I was thinking that different mana would make different ink to use for different runes. I'm hoping scholl isn't so stupid as to not see that Aaliyah is worth more as a blacksmith then a fighter. After all back in the middle ages a lord would guard there sword-smiths vary heavily as one smith could armor many knights, but it can years to train a new smith to a level that there items can be useful.

Ken

I think a Thor style throwing hammer with a return enchantment would be cool

HardhatDoozer

The core of the story is magic smithing and slice of life, with occasional action sequences. This definitely is on point in my opinion. She even leveled her blacksmith skill this chapter. Still a skipping chapter next would be fine too.

HardhatDoozer

He definitely does. I think he’s about 20 chapters behind. But probably worth a re read.

Kelan

Aaliyah should make a list that takes into account all the costs for repairing her armour that happened due to Tabitha and give it to Pacore at the end so she can be reimbursed. As much as it probably wont make a dent in Pacore’s bank its still a friendly power move and a funny one at that imo

Kelan

We’ve just been through a whole arc of people not wanting to constantly see notifications pop up about delays hahaha

Andrew

Thank you!

ZCochraine!%

Thanks for the chapter! Well, at least if she make an engraving ink box she can put the larger collection runes on the outside since she knows those work.

Håkan Friberg

Thanks!

Justin

Thanks for the chapter.

Frank

I really like the dynamic of this chapter. The conversation seems natural and clear, despite the fact that different things happen at the same time. Now that we have a good basis, speeding up sounds good to reduce the time spent grinding skills.

Möwe Tom

Love the chap thanks boy ^^

Camelopardalis

Nice! You really have a knack for crafting crafting, ;). Might want to tweak “ While talking to Sandra, I removing the kaglese arrow shaft from the forge, moving over to my anvil to use my smaller hammer to straighten it out better. ”

Mike G.

Good chapter, thanks!

Mike G.

we see how the enchantments fair on steel. -> fare

Nick

Thanks for the chapter

Jonathan Timm

I've had to cancel my patreon to you which sucks because of financial reasons. Do you still post on royalroad

Mist of Shadows

I'm looking forward to seeing her getting into enchanting, but a bit of skipping through the some days while they work things out is probably a good idea like you said.

Infinate Fail

Although its nice to hear what she plans to do for the future, I would much rather be watching it happen, show not tell and all that. The enchanting is nice and all, but i would much rather her pull out an enchanted piece of gear as a surprise, with a half paragraph monologue about how she pulled it off, than half a chapter about how she lit a log on fire. How its currently being described allows the reader to speculate on the workings of magic and enchanting, but the majority for now is stuff that we already assumed, and could easily be skipped, while the basics are just rushed by while explaining something else to confirm our assumptions.

rasmus1070

Thanks for the chapter. It would be nice with a post about it being late tho. And I can recommend reading the #ideas-to-improve-the-server on your Discord. But other than that, thanks for the chapter : >

Aclys

Seconded, nice chapter with a nice mix of exposition to chew on a bit while being pleasant to read.

Michael son of Jacob

Since you asked, feedback: I feel like this chapter could have been skipped entirely, and the necessary lore addressed in the next chapter that skips around. I didn't feel any emotion here but frustration during the beginning, and mild curiosity when describing enchanting. In terms of chapter to plot progression efficiency, I'd prefer we'd skip these kinds of chapters in future. I'm grateful you're writing; this is just feedback to help tighten up the plot and keep me feeling things as a reader.

Monus

Nice chapter! Thanks :)

Christoffer Gustafsson

That was a good morning read. Excellent chapter.

Michael son of Jacob

Have you booked an appointment with a therapist yet?

Barrett Hess

I haven't read the chapter yet because it's 1am here, but it's nice to see you're alive, Kosnik! We were starting to get worried there for a second.

Kosnik4

Corrections


More Creators