RunFaps
Torsten Hewson
Torsten Hewson patreon

Volume 2 Chapter 2, alternate: Each Day a Blessing

🕑 Added 2021-03-09 20:00:47 +0000 UTC

Comments

Lettered Wolf

I loved this version. The satire on Xiania is even stronger when Xiulan is in the scene for me. To have a 'normal mc' as the foil makes me smile. Jin being a bit scared of a baby was cute.

matthew gilley

This chapter was more filling. Had more depth where the other felt like a quick glossing over. Thank you so much for the consideration!

Ronin_Ryker

Great improvement!!

Chong Go

That works quite nicely! I love the world you've made!

Monus

I liked the og chapter but this one is a lot more interesting and to be honest a lot better. The Jin/Meiling scene is quite amusing now thanks to the characters dynamic. And “What purpose does the lesson serve?” I asked, “Well, what were you trying to learn from it?” Just made me grin so much! Thank you :D

riley st john

Awesome revision I agree that the children talk was a very very good choice.

Luker number 5

I actually really like the children conversation and the addition of Xiulan really filled this out more then the previous version.

Beeees!

Thanks, revision just means an extra chapter to read 😀😀😀. Liked em both, this one more tho

Robert M

+1 for more Xiulan, her perspective as a "normal" strong cultivator is great

Summercat

Yes. Much improved.

Seadrake

Much better.

Oshi

Some Copy Edits: They are posted in the Discord in a better format but I'm posting here as well. I took deep breaths as filling my lungs with sweet spring air. >> I took deep breaths filling my lungs with sweet spring air. The air was almost charged with energy, and it was driving into my soul, stirring me to action.>> The air was charged with energy, and it was driving into my soul, stirring me to action. This could be a stylistic choice but grammatically the almost is not needed. It was the third one she had given to her, and each one before then, Rizzo had guessed right.>> It was the third one she had given to her, Rizzo had guessed right each time. or something like below It was the third one she had given to her, and Rizzo had put a name to each one. but I had no idea how or why he dedicated that >> but I had no idea how or why he decided that Double up on this Meimei had said she didn’t think Xiulan was here to learn farming, exactly, but she had seemed real eager for the first bit.:: Meimei had said she didn’t think Xiulan was here to learn farming, exactly, so You mention this in the exact same way in two lines one after the other. Could be a choice to repeat or could be you forgot prior line.

Joseph

I think this was a improvement

Donncha crowley

Great

To offer a bit of feedback on this chapter, there's stuff I like more about it than the original and stuff I like less. I enjoy the additional bits you've added, especially Xiulan's part, but I feel like the baby/homesick discussion between Meiling and Jin is slightly ill-placed? Don't get me wrong, the discussion itself is great and well-written and I love it a lot, but it did create a bit of a tonal whiplash when we immediately switch from a fairly quiet emotional discussion straight back to wacky fun antics with Gou Ren and Chunky. I'd personally suggest making it its own scene and moving to the end of the chapter instead of the energy drink bit, but obviously it's up to you. The energy drink stuff was a lot of fun too and I'd hardly complain about it sticking around. Also, you have already gone to great lengths to rewrite this chapter for us once already and I don't want you to feel like you need to do it again, especially since I'm of the opinion that both versions are great anyway.

crownfall

I like both versions. I expect the first few chapters of volume 2 to be slower as we warm up into the next arc and plot thread that connects volume 2 (presumably the grandpa returning.) I think the inclusion of xiulan and her dissatisfaction was great, I hope we can see more of her thought process. So far your character arcs have been really satisfying. My favorite characters to see interact with Jin are definitely the Magistrate and Xiulan (grass irelia).

crownfall

bonk! Go to horny jail, Jin

Chris Britt

Way better! Felt more slice of life and less filler

Mani

Oh wow! Much better! Really nice to have it tied together with Meiling asking jin to get the others for dinner. Gives context for checking on everyone. Nice inclusion of the sheep as well, forgot they existed otherwise. Honestly a way better chapter, with real character stuff in it and a small plot thread keeping it together!

closeded

I liked the last version too, but this was a significant improvement.


More Creators