Boldcast patreon

One Piece Live Action Season 1 Discussion & Review

🕑 Added 2023-10-04 07:18:50 +0000 UTC

Comments

IBG_Music

I believe only superman is beating one piece in terms of all time sales. I'm very excited for your journey through the anime. Oda is the master at subtle foreshadowing.

Bernardo Mello

Your react analyzes are the best I've seen on YouTube so far. Looking forward to seeing the one piece (anime) reaction.

Budats

One Piece is actually the best selling manga of all time, worldwide. I checked lots of different sites. Every year it changes like in 2023, it's Blue Lock but so far, no one beat One Piece's record of sales.

Artemis

This is not a spoiler but just an FYI. In the manga the final saga has started so there now is an end in sight which means people thinking that it will go on forever, that is no longer the case. The story is wrapping up. So what better time to start this journey.

Sloth

Pretty much this. The only way we knew for sure they did or didn't have a devil fruit power back in the day was if we saw them swimming, then we knew they didn't have a devil fruit power. Also, a lot of people seem to be thinking they need to clarify things that were misinterpreted from the live action, but nobody needs to do that as they will figure it out as they watch the anime themselves.

Artemis

Naruto is great but it has alot of dues ex machina moments as well. One piece feels alot more consistent in its story telling and writing.

Artemis

I would not recommend one pace, especially for boldcast, Carson specifically looks at the composition and production pacing of a series and alot of that is very prematurely edited with one pace. Certain endings don't match the music for example and you can totally tell, its very awqward. I think one pace is truly for someone that is famililar with the franchise and just wants a refresher but has already seen most of it before.

BirthdayParty

Ignore those people who are saying that it's obvious whether or not something is a Devil Fruit power or not. They're saying it with the hindsight and experience of watching 100+ episodes of One Piece. Some of them definitely asked the same question you were asking when they watched the series for the first time. Heck, I sure did. It definitely gets more obvious whether something is a Devil Fruit or not as you watch the show, but the show doesn't expect you to understand what is or what isn't a Devil Fruit power until later. The people who said those things have just forgotten what it was like for them when they first watched One Piece and are taking the info they know now for granted.

kobehoneylyn

Nicolas LeBlanc

Looking forward to the episodes! I rewatched the first anime episode a few days ago and it was a lot of fun!

Tope

They have a loooong way until the arcs where One Pace becomes more tempting.

Ej Evangelista

i am sooo ready to see yalls reaction to the differences. looking foward to it

EOussama

Close enough (e-oh-sama) but don't beat yourself over it, the way it came out was too good to pass on, one of those moments that randomly get a chuckle out of you. Love you guys.

BOLDcast

lmao its "ay-oh-sama" right? I thought about correcting her but I thought it was funnier for her to try (and I'm not 100%)

SomeoneElse

If they're looking to have discussion about the One Piece anime and critique it, swapping to One Pace wouldn't make sense. I will say I'm an advocate of it for Dressrosa

BOLDcast

thanks man

Sascha

Well they hopefully they try it out later, if they prefer the un edited adaptation it's still one piece at the end of the day. But like think of the "Rome" arc 120 episodes down to 50 just by taking out the fluff.

EOussama

Cuts a lot of good sakuga, has errors in the editing, sometimes audio cuts that make no sense, and many other problems. I won't lie, it's a really good and solid fan project but it's more suited as a rewatch IMO. But then again, as long as Carson and Lindsay are having fun, what version they watch doesn't really matter at the end of the day.

Sascha

Why not? it just cuts out filler scenes not in the managa. It's not that bad at the beginning but eventually that fluff is like half the episodes.

EOussama

I don't think One Pace is a viable option for someone who's watching for the first time.

Sascha

Maybe this has already been answered but, when it comes to the anime, will you guys be watching the filler?(Please god nothing but G8) And what are your thoughts on eventually switching to One Pace? it's not to big a deal until way later, and it would definetly add some complications in uncuts, but the anime adaptations pace does really start to effect the quality of the story eventually.