RunFaps
IHaveHidden
IHaveHidden patreon

Chapter 30 (Proving Grounds)

🕑 Added 2024-03-02 10:46:31 +0000 UTC

Comments

Cain.HERO.Komisarz

I just hope this doesn't turn into Solomon's harem. It will be much more interesting to see interactions other than "romantic" and "love" between Snape and all the girls he sees. For this reason, I kind of liked Snape's relationship with Narcissa.

Jesse

I like where this is going Ashley is way better than lily she was kinda boring and her personality didn’t fit with prince very well compared to Ashley

David Hedges

Also, I'm not really seeing what value this extremely long diversion is going to bring to the story after this point? We as readers need something to look forward to in the story. Just the single plot point of convincing one of many waifus to like him isn't enough by itself for this massive divergence to feel worth it IMO when we have so many more interesting threads in the HP world going on even if most of those have been burnt by the MC's actions and sudden power spike. Ever read a Gamer fic with the MC having instant dungeons and how those always feel boring to read? This is like that but a slight step above. We need more than a vague promise of rewards for the MC. It would be best if it was some character driven motive from the MC involving character growth, but even if it isn't we definitely need something else going on in the story here since it seems to mostly be a mostly-canon rehash of SAO. If there is more to this massive diversion than just a persuading a reluctant waifu and some basically-worthless-now-that-he-is-already-OP rewards to justify the 'on-screen' time invest here, we should really be told so that we as readers have something to be invested towards.

David Hedges

I can't point out exactly why, but this development felt very heavy handed for some reason to me. I'm not even sure what to suggest to fix it cause I can't tell what is 'wrong' here. Maybe it is just me being an amateur writer myself I can see the author's plan with this too easily? But that usually doesn't bother me in-and-of itself, so that probably isn't it. I'm not suggesting to change it either. Also, passing out is an annoying trope. It always feels cheap to me. Lets the author basically do a small time skip instead of dealing with the immediate aftermath of character's actions in a scene. Doesn't matter if it logically makes sense for it to happen or not, it just feels cheap to me when it happens. With that said, he shouldn't be passing out here. While his health in the game will 'kill' him if it reaches zero, there isn't actually 'realistic' health mechanics like going into shock for the most part in SAO, so he shouldn't be passing out at all as far as I am aware.


More Creators