RunFaps
MekanipWrites
MekanipWrites patreon

ACoL Book 2 - Chapter 1 - Something New

🕑 Added 2024-10-20 02:31:06 +0000 UTC

Comments

Abraham Carson

You pretty much echoed my exact sentiments. The prologue is definitely missing something, but I can't put my finger on it. I suspect that it has to do with the fact that writing from the perspective of an animal can be very limiting and so, my prose is rough, and the chapter is short. Maybe it could be moved to a different part of the story.

Joseph Sikorski

EDIT: I just saw this was marked as a teaser rather than a prologue, so maybe don’t put so much weight on my prologue comparison if it’s indeed not that. I’m not sure how to feel about this, I want it somewhere in the story, but as a prologue it feels narratively weak to me. I’ll try to give it another read between everything else but here’s my initial reactions. Keep in mind these may change on subsequent re-reads, as my brain just doesn’t pick everything up the first time around. It’s interesting to see the effects of the Puppeteer on creatures from the perspective of those affected, especially the reveal at the end where yes, they are very definitely still aware and alive in their altered state, or at least they can be because the Puppeteer’s a sadistic bastard like that. It’s been strongly implied that the Puppeteer’s lore can keep them alive through all these resculptings, or can re-alive them if they do somehow manage to kill themselves, trapping them in an endless cycle of suffering. It doesn’t feel quite as strong as the Book 1 prologue, at least to me, but others’ milage may vary. Book 1’s prologue was pure candy to me: Thal’rin and a master Arlock show Salish that Ayrlon’s Tear is doing something freaky, and we immediately get shown that this is a magical world, that the people there at minimum have wings and snouts, Thal’rin is stressed, and that this world exists quite apart from Vincent’s own existence, the last which establishes a narrative contradiction to Vincent’s own viewpoint-to-come. Book 2’s current prologue doesn’t seem to do as much for me, though it is ominous. However, the very end of it is definitely good in that shows the Puppeteer could have left a bunch of still living meat abominations lost and confused and full of contradictory instincts. That part is horrifying in a way that I like. I’m not sure what if anything should be done about it. On the one hand, I feel like it’s good viewpoint experience to know and I want it to exist somewhere, but on the other it feels narratively weak to me. Given they aren’t groundwalkers or zerok, I don’t know that we’d ever get to understand this experience from any of the story characters, unless the zerok can pick up these things from watching the patterns of the abominations and are absolutely terrified by what they find. Zerok understandably don’t fly in storms of any sort, though, let alone Black Storms.


More Creators