RunFaps
alexanderwales
alexanderwales patreon

Thresholder, ch 150, Epilogue: Release Valves

🕑 Added 2025-01-13 18:25:49 +0000 UTC

Comments

iridium248

Without Fenilor, the Culture will likely implode, so this is probably all academic. Their utopia can't exist without a Great Man figure propping it up.

Leaf

It’s the nature of the culture, it reviles the very thing that made it successful. There is no place for dirk in the culture which as far as I’m concerned means that the culture is fundamentally flawed. King dirk was definitely right.

Darryl Greensill

Velli being so eager to purge the Dirks is ominous.

Darryl Greensill

Thank you for a great chapter and a great book! Can I make one request please? Could you find some way to put in the line “but these were special circumstances” somewhere in regard to Dirk’s missions?

Thomas

The highlight of the book for me was the Farfinder's first appearance and the contact with Perry afterwards. Those were fun interactions. I also loved March's ascension to near-full personhood—that was a long time coming. Also, the chapter where Perry finds Felinor's hideout was great. Still remember the creeping tension I had reading it. The King's assassination was the funniest moment. The best fight was Perry vs Third Fervor. The one that ended underwater. This has the best politics, sociology, and worldbuilding of all the volumes. I love the culture. Love how you set it up, the contradictions, the debates and all of it. That said, I do wish there had been more emphasis on the magic—more tinkering with the masks, deeper exploration of the domes etc... All in all, it's a really good volume. I would probably still rank the last volume a bit higher, mostly because I liked the villain (Jeff) and the side characters (Brigitta and crew) more. I'm Iooking forward to the next volume.

Nedardo

Thank you for writing!

Lorenzo

Fantastic chapter, as always :)

patreonizing

>“I worry how it looks,” said Moss. “To the Farfinder, and the people who will come after.” Yeah, it...doesn't look good, honestly. Plan A genuinely would have been ideal, since it shows the culture is strong enough not to *need* to employ an iron fist against the last redoubt. That they aren't afraid of Thirlwell persisting, perhaps even flourishing. And not even their own fist - Markat does have some other majjycks that we haven't seen, but I seriously doubt this kind of stunt would be remotely easy to pull without the Farfinder. (Why are they assisting this coup anyway? I thought they had a pretty noninterventionist bent, and Nima's the one who really couldn't stand the culture...she'd be feeling pretty vindicated by these events!) Plus the fact that Casper does, in fact, grasp the point of release valves, yet is okay with installing a much huger multiversal one vs a local and easily contained one. I have to side with Dirk Faulk here, it genuinely seems like an inconsistent approach that hasn't been thought all the way through. Conformity of thought is a common downfall to things like the culture. What would happen if a literal monarch like the Earth King from The Great Arc shows up? Let alone an actively-hostile threat, once the complacent culture has lost its institutional muscle to defend itself? *That* is the value of competition, having to keep yourself sharp and continuously improving. Fenilor would have understood, as much as he was...uh...sociopathic in praxis. One also has to wonder how much the queen means what she says. If she's honest and forthright, then I'm frankly impressed - Fenilor misjudged her ineptitude for rule, probably shoulda let her brother take over instead. However, if her clone is (grudgingly?) willing to go along with this deception...it's sorta unclear how much clones diverge from their originals, and she's been kept prisoner for quite some time by now, but you'd think such convictions would spring from first principles rather than mere context. Her and Faulk woulda made for good Thresholders. A pity.

Kevin Vermeer

Sometimes, with all the stress of adult life and the world we live in, I like to settle down in a comfy chair and pick up "This Used To Be About Dungeons" or something like it and just lose myself in an utopia (a utopia?) for an hour or two. Other times, though: > “It’ll hold,” said Casper. “We have to believe it will, to fight for it.” Not sure how much I believe in what Fenilor's ideal culture became, or whether its assumptions apply to our own human universe that's almost but not quite post-scarcity... but the sentiment here, believing in a society that's better and working to achieve that, is just palpable and I love it. I'm no Dirk or Fenilor or Moss, I'm hopelessly out of my element when it comes to political science. But AW, I really respect what you do as an author, and I think it's hard to underestimate the way your stories set in fantasy worlds shape the way thousands of people think about the real world.


More Creators